Is It Recordable?
Scenario Q201

Holy Cow: is it recordable?

Verdict: Not recordable
Published 2021-08-15

Question

An employee was waking up in the morning to prepare to go to work when a cow fell through his ceiling and crushed him to death. His house was on a hill and the cow managed to climb onto his roof. Is it recordable?

Answer

NO. The employee was outside normal working hours and not geographically within the worksite. Even if the employee had begun his commute to work when the incident occurred, the commute is specifically listed as an exception and incidents that occur during the commute are not considered work related.

1904.5(a)Basic requirement. You must consider an injury or illness to be work-related if an event or exposure in the work environment either caused or contributed to the resulting condition or significantly aggravated a pre-existing injury or illness. Work-relatedness is presumed for injuries and illnesses resulting from events or exposures occurring in the work environment, unless an exception in §1904.5(b)(2) specifically applies

1904.5(b)(2)(vii)You are not required to record injuries and illnesses if . . . The injury or illness is caused by a motor vehicle accident and occurs on a company parking lot or company access road while the employee is commuting to or from work.

Illustration for the scenario: Holy Cow

#RedBeard #osha #osharecordkeeping #safety #workerscomp #occupationalsafety #recordkeeping #injuries #injury #HR #cow #commute

Illustration for the scenario: Holy Cow

Related scenarios

Q229

Reportable Twice?

An employee is seriously injured at work and is admitted to a hospital. The employer reports the in-patient hospitalization to OSHA…

Not recordable
Q228

Insidious Splinter

On the weekend, at home, an employee received a splinter in his hand while building a wooden loft bed for his daughter. He removed the…

Recordable
Q221

Company Bus

Employees travel to their normal workplace, a remote production site in a mountainous region, in a company-provided bus from a nearby…

Recordable

This is guidance based on 29 CFR Part 1904 and OSHA letters of interpretation. Facts and details may be altered or fictional. As specified by OSHA, the employer is responsible for the final recordability determination.